Why do people think TCE is bad?
There are a number of discussions you can find in forums on the web and blogs of players who religiously follow the teachings of one brass guru or another who try to talk about the Tongue Controlled Embouchure. This is good; discussion is healthy; and at least if people are talking about an idea then that means it is spreading. The problem I see, however, is that the vast majority of these conversations are completely devoid of one thing: participants who knows anything about the subject.
There is a lot of speculation, guess work, fear, and anecdotal evidence from people with very little or no experience of the technique. Many people have tried and failed at TCE, MSC or Superchops and then devote their time to damning the existence of an idea. The question that is rarely asked is whether those same people are actually progressing by following their more traditional ideas…
The truth is that the majority of information available on the subject is poorly explained and poorly or incorrectly demonstrated and the only good book on the subject is out of print.
So here, I propose a solution: Simplify the definition.
One of the biggest problems with TCE not being understood is that the volume of misinformation leads people to believe that there is anything to this method other than this:
TCE means playing with an anchored tongue, between the teeth.
When put in these terms it seems ridiculous that people get so worked up about it all. Sure it raises questions about how that can work, but I can answer all of those questions with reasoned, researched, logical answers. All of the other ideas I write about, including over-blowing, clean articulation, playing with a centered sound, pedal notes, etc. are things that expert players, teachers, and embouchure gurus have been discussing for decades.
There is no requirement that you should use any particular equipment. And once practiced you can play any kind of music that you normally would with a brass instrument perfectly well.
I often like to finish with a quote, so here one is:
David Hickman, when being interviewed about his book Trumpet Pedagogy: A Compendium of Modern Teaching Techniques stated:
My realization that there are “many roads to Rome” came during my studies at the University of Colorado with Dr. Frank Baird. His dissertation is titled A History and Annotated Bibliography of Tutors for Trumpet and Cornet. He summarized the main ideas of hundreds of methods, often sharing some of the more interesting or controversial ones with me. I was amazed and fascinated with all of the different, sometimes opposing, ways of playing and teaching the trumpet. I decided then that I would never laugh at or “put down” any method of playing just because I didn’t use it. By memorizing or referring to various methods other than my own, I have had a much greater success in my teaching than I would have had otherwise. Most teachers are very lucky to have 20-50% success in making their students into fine professionals. I have been fortunate to have perhaps a 98% success rate.
For more information about the Tongue Controlled Embouchure, visit http://tonguecontrolled.info/